Subject: Re: What Did You Watch? 2018-03-07 (Wednesday)
On 3/8/2018 9:41 AM, Arthur Lipscomb wrote:
> On 3/8/2018 4:49 AM, Obveeus wrote:
>> THE MAGICIANS: Margo and Eliot are sentenced to death, but on the
>> good side they get to choose the method. Julia and Fen play with a
>> fairy and try to teach it magic so that it can gain its freedom.
>> Penny and Alice and Kady get stuck in a happy sucking pocket world
>> with Josh...
> When even the characters on the show don't know who Josh is, how am *I*
> supposed to know who Josh is? :-/
We've seen Josh many times before as one of the Brakebill students that
occasionally helps out, but then disappears again into the background.
> I could have sworn the lyrics to his song said he was *not* who he
> looked like. I assumed that meant he was a fake Josh. How did they
> figure out he was the real Josh and everyone else was fake?
I agree. Everything in Josh's lyrics fit the demon character's
plan/persona. Maybe the guy doing the Todd character just cannot sing?
Maybe it was just not enough of a misdirect/puzzle if the room/pocket
world became mostly about Todd instead of the all-but-forgotten Josh?