Subject: Re: WIND RIVER (no spoilers)
On 11/20/2017 10:24 PM, reilloc wrote:
> On 11/15/2017 11:10 AM, moviePig wrote:
>> On 11/15/2017 10:42 AM, william ahearn wrote:
>>> On Wednesday, November 15, 2017 at 9:21:33 AM UTC-5, moviePig wrote:
>>>> The massive snowstorm that threatens Wyoming's already frozen WIND
>>>> reservation is just a head-fake (possibly owing to the story's
>>>> basing on
>>>> "true events"). Instead, the movie follows the investigation -- mostly
>>>> outdoors -- of a grisly and heart-wrenching assault on a young Native
>>>> American woman. Ranger/hunter Jeremy Renner leads the pursuit,
>>>> delivering epigrams both pithy and sententious, and there's a
>>>> end-title that's almost puzzling. But, here, the story is the story,
>>>> and it's in expert -- if frostbitten - hands. Solidly recommended.
>>> Yeah, that needless end title bothered me as well. Ir could have been
>>> incorporated into the script.
>> !!! SOME DESCRIPTION OF NARRATIVE STRUCTURE !!!
>> I was especially taken with the ballsy "cutaway" -- as she knocks on
>> the trailer door -- to the boyfriend answering it (and the progression
>> of scenes that followed). Whoever came up with that very
>> unconventional yet inspired sequence has my admiration. (If it's not
>> fresh enough in your mind, I'm happy to recap.)
> Ballsy, eh? Cheap? It's somewhere between the two. Technically, it's
> cheating: because no law-enforcement character knows what happened
> inside the trailer it can't tie a neat ribbon around the investigation
> or resolution (many dead bad guys), and comes off as a crutch for the
> audience, a group of people who are always presumed to be wanting to be
> led by the nose to a reason they ought to hate somebody and not flinch
> so much at that somebody's bloody death.
> Theatrically, it's been done before--I just can't tell you when.
> Damn movie looks like it was living hell to make and I liked that the
> cops had to clean out two trailers packed with soulless animals that
> needed killing.
Yeah, I appreciated it as a storytelling flourish, for doing the things
you list (...beginning with the elaborate head-fake shootout that
*almost* occurs just before she gets to the door, which, being quelled
by cooler heads, makes us relax on that front.)
- - - - - - - -
YOUR taste at work...