Subject: Re: A lightroom question
On 10/30/17 PDT 5:52 AM, Mayayana wrote:
> "John McWilliams"<firstname.lastname@example.org> wrote
> Listen to The Duck. He knows whereof he speaks. Me, I worked only on V2
> and 3 of LR.....
> What is it I said that you disagree with?
The same corrections that The Duck made.
> That saving out of LR to JPG is lossy?
> That images coming from the camera as JPG
> have lost data?
> That a JPG is actually a bitmap stored in a
> compressed file format?
> Did you actually read what I wrote? I was never
> questioning SD's methods or his explanations
> about LR.
> I've agreed over and over that the process LR
> uses can be used to edit the image without loss,
> inside LR. All I'm saying is that it's important to
> recognize that LR is not somehow magically
> transcending the limitations of JPG. It's merely
> storing data about edits.
I'm pretty sure that he didn't assert the above paragraph.